The Spectator

The Harry Potter controversy continues

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Rebecca Mennecke

More stories from Rebecca Mennecke

Bad Feminist
February 18, 2019

How the omission of the sexual orientation of beloved "Harry Potter" character, Albus Dumbledore, sparked controversy in the LGBTQIA+ community

Some+Harry+Potter+fans+think+the+lack+of+explicit+portrayal+of+the+sexual+orientation+of+Albus+Dumbledore+in+the+new+%22Fantastic+Beasts%22+film+is+problematic.
Back to Article
Back to Article

The Harry Potter controversy continues

Some Harry Potter fans think the lack of explicit portrayal of the sexual orientation of Albus Dumbledore in the new

Some Harry Potter fans think the lack of explicit portrayal of the sexual orientation of Albus Dumbledore in the new "Fantastic Beasts" film is problematic.

Some Harry Potter fans think the lack of explicit portrayal of the sexual orientation of Albus Dumbledore in the new "Fantastic Beasts" film is problematic.

Some Harry Potter fans think the lack of explicit portrayal of the sexual orientation of Albus Dumbledore in the new "Fantastic Beasts" film is problematic.

Advertisement

From Harry Potter’s beginnings in “Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone” in 1997, the world’s favorite lightning-scarred teenager has faced an onslaught of controversy, appearing on banned book lists globally for over twenty years.

The controversy continues with the newest addition to the Harry Potter universe — “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them” — which follows American wizard Newt Scamander as he analyzes and describes magical creatures. The latest dispute revolves around the explicit portrayal of the sexual orientation of the character Albus Dumbledore being omitted in the film.

It was over ten years ago that author J.K. Rowling confirmed she had “always thought Dumbledore was gay.”

In an interview with Entertainment Weekly, Director David Yates asserted that Dumbledore will “not explicitly” be portrayed as gay in the second Fantastic Beasts movie.

Rowling recently responded to criticism about the interview by tweeting, “Being sent abuse about an interview that didn’t involve me, about a screenplay I wrote but which none of the angry people have read, which is part of a five-movie series that’s only one installment in, is obviously tons of fun.”

Rowling may be insinuating that while Dumbledore’s sexual orientation will be left out of the second Fantastic Beasts, it may be exposed in later movies.

“Well, I can’t tell you everything I would like to say because this is obviously a five-part story, so there’s lots to unpack in that relationship,” she said.

Some in defense of Rowling minimizing — or leaving out — Dumbledore’s sexuality added how in many countries, sexual orientations other than heterosexual are less tolerated than in the United States and so some governments would either not allow the film in their theaters or would censor them.

Others observed that it has never been said that Dumbledore is gay in the books, and so Fantastic Beasts is remaining true to textual evidence in the Harry Potter series, rather than on facts added after the series was published.

Caspar Salmon from The Guardian criticized Rowling adding Dumbledore’s sexuality as an afterthought by stating, “Quite how somebody is supposed to be gay without it ever being said, written or observed is for greater minds than mine to fathom.”

Many fans have accused Rowling of queerbaiting — insinuating a same-sex relationship where there ends up being none — in this case, frustrating Harry Potter fans who have awaited the explanation of Dumbledore and his relationship to Grindelwald.

Dumbledore’s sexual orientation being minimized is yet another blatant example of the LGBTQIA+ community’s lack of representation in the film industry and the omission of a detail that greatly contributes to Dumbledore’s story.

I respect the decision to keep Dumbledore’s sexual orientation a more subtle part of his personality for the first film, because Dumbledore has always been a mysterious, private character, and I can understand how the director may want to portray that.

However, I do think Dumbledore’s sexual orientation must be portrayed in later films because otherwise the complex relationship that Rowling established between Dumbledore and Grindelwald makes little sense.

The only way to formulate a solid opinion on the controversy is to see the the film when it comes to theaters Nov. 16, 2018.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
About the Writer
Rebecca Mennecke, Currents Editor

Rebecca "Becca" Mennecke is a second-year creative writing student with a minor in journalism who is thrilled to spend her third semester on staff as The Spectator's Currents Editor. When not editing for The Spectator, Becca can be found with her nose behind a book, watching an ultra-cheesy Hallmark movie or improving her nature photography skills by being in the great outdoors.

Leave a Comment

The Spectator intends for this area to be used to foster healthy, thought-provoking discussion. Comments are expected to adhere to our standards and to be respectful and constructive. As such, we do not permit the use of profanity, foul language, personal attacks or the use of language that might be interpreted as libelous. Comments are reviewed and must be approved by a moderator to ensure that they meet these standards. The Spectator does not allow anonymous comments and requires a valid email address. The email address will not be displayed but will be used to confirm your comments.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Left
  • The Harry Potter controversy continues

    Opinion

    Print books are undeniably better than e-books

  • The Harry Potter controversy continues

    Opinion

    Missing white woman syndrome

  • The Harry Potter controversy continues

    Opinion

    Are the Oscars really worth all the hype?

  • The Harry Potter controversy continues

    Opinion

    Social media stunt or cry for help?

  • The Harry Potter controversy continues

    Opinion

    Banning plastic straws isn’t going to save the environment

  • The Harry Potter controversy continues

    Column

    Horoscopes?

  • The Harry Potter controversy continues

    Column

    Seeking Solace

  • The Harry Potter controversy continues

    Column

    Bad Feminist

  • The Harry Potter controversy continues

    Opinion

    Onslaught of layoffs in media industry is distressing and casts grim light on future of journalism

  • The Harry Potter controversy continues

    Opinion

    Don’t hop on the Disney remake hate bandwagon

Navigate Right
The official student newspaper of University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire since 1923.
The Harry Potter controversy continues